Christian talk show host Serenity Williams may be at the top of her game professionally, but when her fiancè calls off their wedding, she learns the true price of fame. He can't deal with her popularity, and when he walks out, she knows it will be a long time before she lets another pride-filled, pastor into her heart. Then she gets assigned an interview with the charismatic Pastor Phillip McKnight. Delighted that she now has the opportunity to expose the arrogance of ego-driven pastors to the world, she accepts the assignment.

However, Serenity isn't prepared for the real man behind the pulpit. Recently divorced, Phillip is broken from his experiences, and soon his surprising humility causes Serenity not to want to ruin him, but instead to un-break his heart. . .  But Serenity will need the Lord to fix her heart and change her mind about male preachers before she and Phillip can become all they were meant to be to each other.